Which adventure bike reigns supreme? bmw f900xr vs honda africa twin

In the realm of adventure motorcycles, two titans stand tall: the BMW F900XR and the Honda Africa Twin. Both machines embody a blend of on-road prowess and off-road capability, catering to riders seeking versatility and exploration. This comprehensive comparison aims to delve into the intricate details of these two formidable machines, analyzing their strengths, weaknesses, and ultimately determining which emerges as the superior choice for adventure enthusiasts.

Engine and Performance

BMW F900XR: The F900XR boasts an 895cc parallel-twin engine, delivering a smooth and responsive power delivery. With 105 horsepower and 64 lb-ft of torque, it provides ample grunt for both highway cruising and spirited off-road riding.

Honda Africa Twin: The Africa Twin counters with a 1084cc parallel-twin engine, offering a slightly higher output of 101 horsepower and 75 lb-ft of torque. Its low-end torque is particularly impressive, making it well-suited for navigating technical terrain and carrying heavy loads.

Handling and Suspension

BMW F900XR: The F900XR features a nimble and agile chassis, thanks to its lightweight construction and a well-balanced weight distribution. Its fully adjustable suspension provides a comfortable and controlled ride, both on tarmac and off-road.

Honda Africa Twin: The Africa Twin offers a more planted and stable feel, owing to its longer wheelbase and a more upright riding position. Its Showa suspension system is renowned for its excellent damping characteristics, effectively absorbing bumps and rough terrain.

Electronics and Features

BMW F900XR: The F900XR comes equipped with a comprehensive suite of electronics, including traction control, ABS, and ride modes. It also offers a large TFT display, providing clear and intuitive information to the rider.

Honda Africa Twin: The Africa Twin matches the F900XR’s electronic offerings, with switchable traction control and ride modes. Its TFT display is smaller but equally functional, displaying essential data and navigation information.

Off-Road Capabilities

BMW F900XR: Despite its on-road bias, the F900XR exhibits surprising off-road prowess. Its long-travel suspension and optional knobby tires enable it to tackle moderate off-road conditions with confidence.

Honda Africa Twin: The Africa Twin excels in off-road environments. Its long-travel suspension, advanced traction control system, and optional off-road tires make it a formidable companion for serious adventurers.

On-Road Comfort and Touring

BMW F900XR: The F900XR prioritizes on-road comfort with an upright riding position and a plush seat. Its wind protection and ample storage space make it an ideal choice for long-distance touring.

Honda Africa Twin: The Africa Twin offers a more upright and commanding riding position, providing excellent visibility and control. Its comfortable seat and adjustable windscreen enhance its touring capabilities.

Price and Value

BMW F900XR: The BMW F900XR has a base price of around $13,000. Its comprehensive feature set and impressive performance justify its premium price tag.

Honda Africa Twin: The Honda Africa Twin starts at approximately $14,000. Its legendary reliability and off-road prowess make it a compelling choice for riders seeking a versatile and rugged adventure motorcycle.

Which is Right for You?

The choice between the BMW F900XR and the Honda Africa Twin ultimately depends on your individual needs and riding preferences.

• For riders seeking a versatile adventure motorcycle with a strong on-road bias, the BMW F900XR is an excellent choice. Its nimble handling, comfortable ergonomics, and impressive electronics suite make it a pleasure to ride both on tarmac and light off-road trails.

• For riders who prioritize serious off-road adventures and rugged reliability, the Honda Africa Twin is the clear winner. Its unmatched off-road capabilities, proven durability, and advanced traction control system make it the ideal companion for exploring remote and challenging terrain.

Alternatives to Consider

If neither the BMW F900XR nor the Honda Africa Twin fully meets your requirements, consider these alternatives:

• KTM 890 Adventure: A nimble and versatile adventure motorcycle with a playful and sporty character.
• Triumph Tiger 900: A well-rounded adventure machine offering a balance of on-road comfort and off-road capability.
• Ducati Multistrada 950: An Italian-inspired adventure motorcycle with a strong focus on performance and style.

Conclusion: A Tale of Two Titans

The BMW F900XR and the Honda Africa Twin stand as two exceptional adventure motorcycles, each with its own strengths and appeals. The F900XR excels as a versatile all-rounder, while the Africa Twin reigns supreme in off-road environments. Ultimately, the best choice for you hinges on your riding style, budget, and the type of adventures you seek.

FAQ

Q: Which motorcycle has a more powerful engine?
A: The Honda Africa Twin has a slightly more powerful engine, with 101 horsepower compared to the F900XR’s 105 horsepower.

Q: Which motorcycle is better for off-road riding?
A: The Honda Africa Twin is the superior choice for serious off-road riding, thanks to its long-travel suspension, advanced traction control system, and optional off-road tires.

Q: Which motorcycle is more comfortable for long-distance touring?
A: Both the F900XR and the Africa Twin offer comfortable ergonomics and ample storage space, but the F900XR has a slight edge in terms of wind protection and on-road comfort.