Scrambler comparison guide: bmw r ninet scrambler vs triumph scrambler 1200

In the world of motorcycles, the scrambler segment has emerged as a popular choice for riders seeking a blend of retro styling, off-road capability, and everyday practicality. Two prominent contenders in this category are the BMW R nineT Scrambler and the Triumph Scrambler 1200. In this comprehensive comparison, we delve into the key differences between these two exceptional machines, helping you make an informed decision about which one suits your riding needs and preferences.

Design: Retro Roots with Modern Touches

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Embodies a timeless aesthetic, inspired by classic scramblers of the 1960s. Its exposed air-cooled boxer engine, spoked wheels, and upright riding position exude a raw and rugged appeal.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Blends traditional scrambler elements with contemporary design cues. The round headlight, high-mounted exhaust, and wire-spoked wheels retain the classic character, while the sleek bodywork and LED lighting add a touch of modernity.

Engine: Power and Character

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Powered by an air-cooled, 1170cc boxer engine, delivering 110 horsepower and 85 lb-ft of torque. Its unique firing order produces a distinctive and throaty exhaust note.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Equipped with a liquid-cooled, 1200cc parallel-twin engine, generating 90 horsepower and 81 lb-ft of torque. The engine offers a smooth and linear power delivery, with a characteristic growl.

Handling: On and Off the Road

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Features a steel tubular frame, 43mm upside-down forks, and a paralever rear suspension. Its handling is agile and responsive on both paved and unpaved surfaces.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Utilizes a tubular steel frame, 45mm Showa upside-down forks, and a monoshock rear suspension. It provides a comfortable and composed ride, with good stability and off-road capability.

Technology: Modern Conveniences

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Offers a minimalist approach to technology, with a simple analog speedometer and tachometer. However, optional features include ABS, traction control, and heated grips.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Features a more comprehensive instrument panel, including a digital speedometer, tachometer, gear indicator, and trip computer. It also offers advanced rider aids such as ABS, traction control, and multiple riding modes.

Comfort and Ergonomics

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Provides a comfortable and upright riding position, with a wide handlebar and a slightly forward-set footpeg position. The seat is firm but supportive.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Offers a more relaxed and cruiser-like riding position, with a wide seat, mid-mounted footpegs, and a slightly swept-back handlebar.

Price and Availability

BMW R nineT Scrambler: Starting at approximately $13,000, the R nineT Scrambler is a premium offering in the scrambler segment.

Triumph Scrambler 1200: Starting at approximately $11,000, the Scrambler 1200 offers greater value for money, with a more comprehensive feature set.

Which One is Right for You?

The choice between the BMW R nineT Scrambler and the Triumph Scrambler 1200 ultimately depends on your individual preferences and riding style.

If you prioritize:

• Timeless styling and raw character
• Distinctive engine sound
• Agile handling

Then the BMW R nineT Scrambler is your choice.

If you value:

• Modern design with subtle retro touches
• Smooth and linear power delivery
• Advanced technology and rider aids
• Comfortable and relaxed riding position

Then the Triumph Scrambler 1200 is a better fit.

Beyond the Showdown: Other Considerations

Customization Options: Both the R nineT Scrambler and Scrambler 1200 offer extensive customization options, allowing you to personalize your ride to match your taste and riding needs.

Accessories: A wide range of accessories is available for each model, including luggage, crash bars, and performance upgrades.

Community Support: Both BMW and Triumph have dedicated communities of owners and enthusiasts, providing support and resources for riders.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Which bike has better off-road capability?

A: The BMW R nineT Scrambler has a slightly better suspension setup for off-road riding, but both bikes are capable of handling light off-road trails.

Q: Is the Triumph Scrambler 1200 more fuel-efficient?

A: Yes, the Scrambler 1200 has a more fuel-efficient engine, with an average fuel consumption of around 45 mpg compared to the R nineT Scrambler‘s 40 mpg.

Q: Which bike is more expensive to maintain?

A: Both bikes require regular maintenance, but the BMW R nineT Scrambler may have slightly higher maintenance costs due to its air-cooled engine and more complex design.