Head-to-head: honda africa twin vs bmw gs 1200 – which adventure beast reigns supreme?

For adventure enthusiasts, the Honda Africa Twin and BMW GS 1200 are iconic motorcycles that ignite dreams of exploring the unknown. Both machines are renowned for their off-road capabilities, versatility, and legendary reliability. In this comprehensive comparison, we delve into the key differences between the Honda Africa Twin and the BMW GS 1200, helping you make an informed decision about which adventure steed is right for you.

Powertrain and Performance

The Africa Twin is powered by a 1084cc parallel-twin engine that produces 101 horsepower and 75 lb-ft of torque. The GS 1200, on the other hand, boasts a 1254cc boxer-twin engine that generates 134 horsepower and 106 lb-ft of torque. While the BMW has a clear edge in power, the Africa Twin’s lighter weight gives it a slight advantage in acceleration and agility.

Handling and Suspension

Both motorcycles are equipped with sophisticated suspension systems, but their setups differ. The Africa Twin features a Showa fork and shock with 9.1 inches of travel, while the GS 1200 has a Telelever front suspension and a Paralever rear suspension with 7.9 inches of travel. The Africa Twin’s longer suspension travel makes it better suited for rough terrain, while the GS 1200’s Telelever system provides excellent stability on paved roads.

Electronics and Features

The Africa Twin and the GS 1200 are both packed with electronic aids, including traction control, ABS, and ride modes. However, the GS 1200 offers a wider range of features, such as adaptive cruise control, hill-start assist, and a tire pressure monitoring system. The Africa Twin’s electronics suite is more focused on off-road performance, with features like a switchable rear ABS system and a gravel mode.

Comfort and Ergonomics

Both motorcycles offer comfortable seating positions, but the GS 1200 has a slight edge in this area. The GS 1200’s adjustable seat and handlebar position allow for a wide range of rider sizes and preferences. The Africa Twin‘s seat is also adjustable, but the handlebar position is fixed.

Off-Road Performance

The Africa Twin is renowned for its off-road prowess, with its long-travel suspension, lightweight chassis, and narrow profile. The GS 1200 is also a capable off-roader, but its heavier weight and larger dimensions make it less suited for technical terrain.

On-Road Performance

On paved roads, the GS 1200 shines with its superior power and stability. The Telelever front suspension provides excellent handling and feedback, while the adaptive cruise control makes highway riding a breeze. The Africa Twin is still a capable on-road performer, but its shorter suspension travel and lighter weight make it less comfortable on long stretches of asphalt.

Price and Value

The Honda Africa Twin starts at $14,499, while the BMW GS 1200 starts at $16,895. Both motorcycles offer a wide range of accessories and options, which can significantly increase their price. Ultimately, the best value depends on your individual needs and preferences.

The Verdict

The Honda Africa Twin and the BMW GS 1200 are both excellent adventure motorcycles, but they cater to different types of riders. The Africa Twin is the better choice for riders who prioritize off-road performance and agility, while the GS 1200 is better suited for riders who want a more comfortable and well-equipped motorcycle that excels on both paved and unpaved roads.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Which motorcycle is more reliable?
A: Both the Honda Africa Twin and the BMW GS 1200 have a reputation for reliability, but the Africa Twin has a slight edge in this area.

Q: Which motorcycle has a better resale value?
A: The BMW GS 1200 typically has a better resale value than the Honda Africa Twin.

Q: Which motorcycle is easier to maintain?
A: The Honda Africa Twin is generally easier to maintain than the BMW GS 1200, as it has a simpler design and fewer complex systems.